|
First-person shooter, real-time strategy, sports, action, puzzle. These are just a few of the genres that every videogame falls under. Sometimes, however, these don’t tell the whole story. To call Katamari Damacy just a “puzzle game” is to overlook its charming ridiculousness. To call Zombie Nation a “shooter” ignores the fact that the point is to control an inexplicably large, disembodied zombie-head that destroys cities while simultaneously saving the people whose city you are in the process of destroying. Genre labels have their purpose, but sometimes they overlook important quirks. That’s where I come in.
-- by Christian Porter This month’s
heap:
It’s an unfortunate fact of life that, any time a hit (typically sci-fi or
family) movie is released, a videogame adaptation won’t be far behind.
However, there are rare times when game companies, desperate for ideas, work
with licenses that nobody has cared a damn about for decades. These are just
a few of the results.
Buck
Rogers: Countdown to Doomsday (SG)
First popularized in
1920s comics and radio dramas, Buck Rogers is back. But grab your 20D,
nerdbombers, because this ain’t your grandpappy’s Buck Rogers—it’s much, much
nerdier.
In this game, you create
a party of six adventurers and traipse around a generic sci-fi setting,
occasionally getting into turn-based fights with an emphasis on tactics. Characters move like
someone doing the robot in a strobe light—choppy and slow. Though its tactics-based
battle system isn’t bad, this game lacks polish of any kind. Presumably, the
game's developers knew the only people who would care enough to buy this game
were the same dorks playing the Buck Rogers LARPs that were available at the
same time, so they didn’t bother expending too much effort.
SG:
Buck Rogers
Fun
Novelty
Audio
Visuals
Controls
Replay Value
Overall:
3.33
4
4
3.5
3
1.5
4
Felix The Cat (NES)
Like Buck Rogers, Felix’s
roots can also be traced back to the 1920s and, for reasons unknown, he was
also was made into a modern videogame around the same time the Sega Genesis
Buck Rogers game came out. Truth be told, this is
actually a pretty good game. You play as Felix and collect little Felix-head
emblems to gain power-ups, healing items and 1-ups while you're avoiding
enemies. It’s a basic platformer, but the game actually pulls it off well.
However, it’s really, really easy and seems to have been made with younger
children in mind. Which leads me to wonder: Why would you base a young
children’s video game on a license that was out-dated when my parents were
children?
Regardless, this game is
actually worth picking up and giving a play if you’re looking for a platformer
you can cruise through without thinking too much.
NES:
Felix the Cat
Fun
Novelty
Audio
Visuals
Controls
Replay Value
Overall:
6.08
6
6
6
5
7
6.5
Mission: Impossible (NES)
Hold on, I know what
you're thinking: “Fuck you! Mission Impossible is too culturally relevant!
Tom Cruise has been schlepping those movies out every few years since the
mid-90s!” You’d be right if I was
talking about the N64 Mission Impossible game, but I’m not. I’m talking about
the rip-your-goddamned-hair-out hard NES M:I game that was made years after
the series had ended and a few years before those crappy movies were made.
I’m going to let you in
on a little Top of the Heap secret: I don’t play all the way through all
these games, and I don’t read their manuals. In this case I actually broke
and read the manual after sitting around getting shot, hit by cars and
arrested by helicopters for a half hour. After reading the manual, I realized
that I still didn't know what the hell I was doing and decided that the game
must suffer for this reason. So I gave it a lame score even though it might
be a good game if I sat around and figured it out. Now that’s the mark of a
dedicated game journalist.
NES:
Mission -
Impossible
Fun
Novelty
Audio
Visuals
Controls
Replay Value
Overall:
4.25
3.5
4
5
5
5
3 Tom
and Jerry: War of the Whiskers (GCN) With the fighting game
market dominated by the ultra-violent (Mortal Kombat) and the scantily clad
(DOA), War of the Whiskers offers a fighting game that the kids can get in
on. Unfortunately, it’s based on a license that kids haven’t given really a
shit about in decades.
This fighting game brings
very little to the table other than a stale license and well-worn gameplay.
Although, even if it is a bit dull, surprisingly enough, I wouldn’t go as far
as to call the game terrible. Fun…not so much, but it isn’t terrible, and
because of that this game far exceeded my expectations. If you’ve got kids
and you don’t want them playing stuff with blood and boobies, and you can
convince them that Tom and Jerry were really cool in the 40s, then maybe you
can pawn this off on your kid.
GCN:
Tom & Jerry: War
of the Whiskers
Fun
Novelty
Audio
Visuals
Controls
Replay Value
Overall:
4.33
3.5
4
5
5
4.5
4
The Lone Ranger (NES)
When you think of a Lone
Ranger videogame you think “mindless shooter.” This actually isn’t the case.
The Lone Ranger puts a lot on its plate: RPG, shooter, platformer, and it’s
even got primitive first-person shooter parts you can play with the NES
Zapper. Even more surprising is that it does all of these things pretty
well!
The game is kind of like
a combination of Zelda II, Castlevania, Hogan’s Alley, Ikari Warriors, Friday
the 13th and Star Tropics. That’s quite a combination and sounds like very
high praise, and it is, but it should be mentioned that The Lone Ranger
doesn’t play any better than any of these games that it is similar to except
for maybe Friday the 13th and Hogan’s Alley. Well worth picking up if
you feel like playing a novel and challenging game.
NES:
The Lone Ranger
Fun
Novelty
Audio
Visuals
Controls
Replay Value
Overall:
6.08
5.5
7.5
5
5.5
7
6 That’s all there is for
this out-of-date heap. The top of this
well-aged heap is:
It’s a tie! Felix the Cat &
The Lone Ranger
It’s a halcyon day for
Top of the Heap. Not only did no games get below a 3 this time around, but
two even got above a 5 and tied at exactly 6.08 each. Rather than extending
the rating system out a decimal place to decide a winner, I’m giving the
coveted Top of the Heap Bowling Trophy Gif to both games. Felix the Cat does
Platforming games for younger players as well as The Lone Ranger does the more
difficult 1,000-genres-at-once game.
-- Christian Porter {06-2007} Rate this article — |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Got an idea for a future Top of The Heap topic? Then send me one of them thar new-fangled electronic-mails to cporter (the “at” sign) gamecola.net. You can’t very well expect me to do my own legwork, after all. |
|
Past Editions of Top of the Heap
May 2007: Games
Starring Jean-Claude Van Damme |